Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Vairagya - The art of giving up

Hello, it is nice to be back after a brief holiday. I would like to respond to Shuba's question first.


Anumānā :- Ma means to measure, that is to understand something. Anu - means to follow . So Anumānā is to arrive at an understanding following a lead where direct perception is not possible. Arthapatti, Upamānā etc fall under the broad classification of Anumānā. (Anumānā is an interesting and big subject. Maybe we could discuss this as a separate topic later on.)

Sūtra I.2 states:

Yoga is "Citta Vritti Nirodha" - to move towards, reach and stay at the state of 'Nirodha'. Explaining the means to reach this state, Sage Patanjali highlights the inseparable twins, Abhyāsa and Vairāgya [practice and dispassion] as the first and foremost tools. They, like the two wheels of a bicycle, must roll together and synchronise to ensure a smooth forward movement and progress.

Regarding abhyāsa, practice, Patanjali explains in detail 'how to practice' in Sūtra I.14. Practice comprises [i] a long term regime [ii] must be done without a break, not in fits and starts [iii] done with an element of trust and belief [iv] one should enjoy the practice and be enthusiastic about it.

If these four encompass the practice, it rests on a strong foundation and bears fruitful results.

In Sūtra-s I.15 and I.16 Patanjali talks about the second wheel Vairāgya, [the state where 'Rāgam' having gone], one naturally restrains from doing things that hinder progress. He avers "When the senses are under control [Vasikāra], there is no thirst, and when there is no thirst, no force entices, resulting in dispassion". Very logical and fundamental. But the crucial point is how to reach the state of Vasikāra. It looks like Patanjali has stated what Vairāgyam is without any guidance whatsoever on how to achieve this.

The state of Vasikāra is the fourth and last step in the ascent towards vairāgya. By stating Vasikāra, Patanjali has included the other three steps that one has to climb in order to reach the fourth. We learn from 'Sānkhya Karika', specifically the commentary on sutra 23 to understand this.

The four steps are [i] Yatamāna [ii] Vyatireka [iii] Ekendriya [iv] Vasikāra.

Step I

Yatamānā:- comes from the sound Yat - to align, to make a beginning - a state of endeavour. To identify the things that weigh one down, distract and prevent one from moving towards the goal. Having identified them, to take a 'Sankalpa', a resolution to overcome and eradicate them is the first step, Yatamānam.

Step II

Vyatireka:- comes from the word 'Vyāti' - meaning to go beyond. It is to go beyond a mere resolution and actually implement. There are three steps to this. [1] classify your indriyas in terms of control, from easy to very difficult. [2] develop the mental capability to control them. [3] abandon those that are easy to give up and slowly progress.

Step III

Ekendriya:- having listed out the senses, take them one at a time. Select and tackle the rāga-s one by one and slowly work towards eradicating each. Finally, all the senses are purified and incapable of drawing and dragging the mind along. However these emotions continue to dwell in one last instrument - the mind in the form of craving. This is eka-indriyam, one organ stage.

Step IV

Vasikāra:- Further practice should reduce and eliminate this craving also. This cessation of attraction towards both sensuous and supersensuous objects of enjoyment even when they are well within our grasp is called Vasikāra Samjna.

So as with Abhyāsa, Patanjali has chalked out a path to progress for Vairāgya also.

All this looks complicated. Therefore Sri Krishnamacarya, the legend, says Vairāgya is simple if we just follow four golden rules assiduously.

Whatever you want to avoid,

1.Do not think about it

2.Even if you think of it, do not see it.

3.Even if you happen to see it, do not go near it.

4.Even if you go near it, do not engage with it.

As simple as that. ALL THE BEST

8 comments:

kamla said...

It is strange that although most Indian languages are all derived from Sanskrit as the base...while 'Atha' also means NOW in Marathi...the word 'Anumana' means To DOUBT in Telugu !!
Kamla Ravikumar

Unknown said...

If I miss my yoga sutra class, I now have this online resource. Thanks!

One Sanskrit word can have several different meanings. 'Anumana' means "guesstimate" in Malayalam. Tamil is the only south Indian language that does not have any roots in Sanskrit. Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam all have lots of Sanskrit words in them.
Geetha Ganapathy

Graeme said...

Thank you very much Sridhar for inspiring me with this latest analysis.

First of all I would like to present my view on leanrning and understanding. When it comes to tackling a philosophical viewpoint my approach is to subject the argument to intense criticism. In other words I try to see if I can find fault with or disprove an argument or find instances where it does not hold true. If I find that all my efforts to disprove it are in vain, I will then accept the proposition. Otherwise I would be accepting an idea purely on faith with no deep conviction and therefore it is less likely that I would ¨follow¨the guidance.

On the subject of vairagya is seems logical that one must develop dispassion in order to progress with meditation - but one could also say that meditation can also help to develop dispassion.

If one is continually driven to fulfill desires then one is not in a balanced state for progression in meditation.

So how does one free oneself from distraction from desires which may be based on instinct and deeply ingrained into our psyche? I don´t claim to have the answer since I haven´t yet been successul in this. What I would say is that from my own personal experience (which may be unique to me alone) trying to ¨not think¨ about an object of desire is futile. It seems that the more you try to force the mind to not think of something the more determined and stubborn the mind becomes to do exactly the opposite.

I put forward my views not to draw attention to myself or to try to impress or be argumentative. But I find the process helps me to develop my ideas and I hope may open up some debate amongst other followers of this analysis of the sutras of Patanjali.

Graeme

kamla said...

I would like to comment on Greame's words..."So how does one free oneself from distraction from desires which may be based on instinct and deeply ingrained into our psyche?"
Isn't meditation one solution which teaches you to focus that wavering mind?...by trying "not think" you are only running away from the solution.The challenge lies in trying to confront that problem and solve it.
Kamla

Alagu Muthu said...

Dear Shridhar,
VAIRAGHYA....the art of giving up!! What an apt topic for your New year Blogspot and so lucidly explained.
So many of us make resolutions for the New year and only Vairaghya can keep us from breaking them !!Some of our desires are so deeply woven into our psyche, they are indeed difficult to give up...I for one have always believed..Why should one give up something one enjoys and is really not doing any great harm to you.....but I am slowly beginning to realise both ABHYASA and VAIRAGHYAMS essential
significance to ones progressive pathto reach the goal of yoga.
Being aware of ones desire and indulgence of it is perhaps the first step we need to take and then we must learn to control the senses and strenghten the mind through focus and meditation....I do hope sincerely that all of us trying will gain some progress through our own determination in 2010...with the blessings and guidance of our teachers
Thank you for bringing two very important aspects of yoga to our attention.

Shuba Kukillaya said...

I would like to share with Graeme what Ramana Maharishi said with regard to 'not thinking' about something. He compared the mind to a cow, that insists on straying from its shed, no matter that such wandering only brings it trouble. He said no amount of force will help, the cow will wander every chance it gets. Its best to coax it back to its shed by offering it some choice thing and gently leading it back. By this repeated act, the cow will come to realise that the best place for it is its shed and will cease to wander. Likewise, a mind the is repeatedly brought back to some better thought, whenever an unwanted thought arises will soon turn automatically to it always.
Shuba

j.s.shivakumar said...

Dear Sir

My reflection on Vairagya:
the art of giving up is not to have attachment/preoccupations towards the desire and the result thereof.The very fact that i need to give up is because i have something (may be a craving ) and this some thing persists always (a wandering mind)leading to happiness and sorrows.

Vairagya to me is a state of equibillurium in the mind.

J.S.Shivakumar

Unknown said...

2AE3F4C4